Lottery Luck Turns Sour: Player Wins $1 Million After Spending $50, But $360,000 Disappears

According to The Sun, Corbblin Dixon hit the jackpot after purchasing a $50 scratch-off ticket at a Publix supermarket in Orlando, Florida, winning a staggering $1 million. With odds of about one in 274,000, Dixon secured the second-place prize, bringing him unexpected fortune.

Choosing the Lump Sum

Dixon faced a crucial decision on how to collect his winnings. Opting for the lump sum payment meant he would walk away with $640,000. However, this choice also resulted in $360,000 being deducted immediately due to taxes.

Understanding Tax Implications

Since the prize amount exceeded $5,000, Dixon was subject to a 24% federal tax rate on his winnings. While he could potentially be pushed into a higher income tax bracket—paying up to 37%—he was fortunate that Florida does not tax lottery winnings, allowing him to keep more of his prize.

Comparing State Tax Policies

Florida is one of the few states that exempts lottery winnings from state taxes, similar to California and Texas. New Hampshire, South Dakota, and Tennessee also have no taxes on lottery prizes. In contrast, states like New York impose hefty taxes, requiring winners to pay 10.9% in state taxes on top of federal obligations, while Maryland, New Jersey, and Oregon levy rates of 8% or more.

Lump Sum vs. Annuity Payments

Winners often debate whether to take a lump sum or opt for an annuity, which provides staggered annual payments over several decades. For instance, Mega Millions winners receive an initial payment followed by 29 annual payments, each increasing by 5%.

Also read: SNAP Recipients Alert: $292 Food Stamps Available Through October 28—How to Claim

The Risks of Taking a Lump Sum

Financial expert Robert Pagliarini cautioned that while the lump sum option can be enticing, it comes with significant risks. “If you take the lump sum, you have to realize that if you start making mistakes or bad investments, there’s no do-over,” he explained. He noted that the annuity option allows for more flexibility and time to manage newfound wealth responsibly.

Common Mistakes Among Winners

Lotto lawyer Andrew Stoltmann indicated that around 90% of lottery winners mistakenly choose the lump sum option, often leading to financial difficulties in the years following their win. As such, winners should carefully weigh their options and consider the long-term implications of their choices.